In November of 1966, in anticipation of our new building which was designed to provide a comprehensive youth program, an outline was developed to envision the kind of youth activities to make the church the very center of our young people’s lives. We believe "that it is in the fellowship of the Christian Church that our youth will find the very finest and happiest way of life". On May 5, 1967, the St. Matthew Youth Center opened its doors. Two thousand seven (2007) will be the center's 40th year of community service.

The St. Matthew Youth Center, "The Matts", is open to students in grades 6 through 12 from mid September to the end of May. There is a yearly $5.00 membership fee (must show school I.D. card). The hours are Wednesdays and Thursdays, 7:00-9:00 PM and Fridays, 7:00-10:00 PM. Activities include: basketball, ping pong, pool, air hockey, foosball, arcade games, snack bar, and TV lounge. Twice a month on Thursdays, the center opens one hour earlier for Bible Study.

The supervising staff are members of St. Matthew. They provide a safe environment, Bible Study leadership, tutoring and Christian friendship. For forty years, the center has offered a place for young people to gather with other young people: a joyous Christian atmosphere, for recreation, fellowship and social activities.